Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Thought experiment, based on nothing but speculation and very unlikely to occur, but curious what others would think...

Say Bama decides to bring Cig home? An offer he can't refuse...

Would you be willing to accept that if we then hired DeBoer in a de facto trade?

I would not take that as a straight up trade, but under the hypothetical condition where CCC is 100% gone, this scenario would very obviously cement Cig's legacy in terms of elevating the program.

After just one year! It would be hard to be mad at him. But please don't leave CCC...

Just for the sake of conversation

DeBoer is no slouch (to put it lightly) and still just 50. Say they lose to LSU and/or Auburn and their boosters get antsy... if you squint, you can sort of see it. I feel like Texas, Bama and UGA would be the only three schools that could truly pull whoever they want no matter how good of a fight the current school puts up.

Brian Kelly left ND for LSU and hasn't had any better luck down there. CCC specifically referenced BK as another coach who came up through D2, so I think he does take notice of that sort of thing and may have an appreciation for the grass not always being greener... Call it sunshine or cope, I think at a certain age most people recognize there is something to be said about being a big fish in a small pond/creating the culture/setting the expectation vs. stepping into the higher profile, higher intensity, more volatile role. 

Posted
16 hours ago, Dave from Dayton said:
I was somewhat surprised that Indiana is now rated in the top ten.  Usually, a team has to beat a highly ranked team to get up there.  Indiana has not.
 
Maybe the best opponent yet is Washington which does have a winning record.  Barely.  5 - 4, 3 - 3.  And Nebraska also has a winning record but is on life support.  5 - 4, 2 - 4.
 
Wow.   Has Michigan fallen off the pace, or what?!  No surprise, but ouch.
 
Indiana hosts Michigan, then runs into reality at OSU and then hosts Purdon't.
 
I am very pro Indiana.  But please be somewhat conservative in assessing IU's performance against a not really too tough schedule.    
 
Cignetti is superb.  But the big boys are too.  Heady stuff.

I get what you're saying but IU has absolutely destroyed all those teams. That is what a good team does.

Posted
16 hours ago, Dave from Dayton said:
I was somewhat surprised that Indiana is now rated in the top ten.  Usually, a team has to beat a highly ranked team to get up there.  Indiana has not.
 
Maybe the best opponent yet is Washington which does have a winning record.  Barely.  5 - 4, 3 - 3.  And Nebraska also has a winning record but is on life support.  5 - 4, 2 - 4.
 
Wow.   Has Michigan fallen off the pace, or what?!  No surprise, but ouch.
 
Indiana hosts Michigan, then runs into reality at OSU and then hosts Purdon't.
 
I am very pro Indiana.  But please be somewhat conservative in assessing IU's performance against a not really too tough schedule.    
 
Cignetti is superb.  But the big boys are too.  Heady stuff.

Tennessee- looked like poop all year

PSU- when comparing our results vs. theirs... there really isn't a comparison. ours have been significantly better

 

Through 9 weeks.... it's pretty clear we should be ranked T10, and actually more like 6th, at the lowest. If you are a great team.... you don't get beat @Ark, if you are a great team you don't only beat Bowling Green by 7 at home. 

 

Tennessee and PSU have handled NO ONE. 

"please be somewhat conservative in assessing IU's performance" No. We have lost 1 quarter all year. 1. Call it what it is... Indiana is a T10 team. They've shown that for 9 weeks. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Certified Sunshine Pumper said:

Tennessee- looked like poop all year

PSU- when comparing our results vs. theirs... there really isn't a comparison. ours have been significantly better

 

Through 9 weeks.... it's pretty clear we should be ranked T10, and actually more like 6th, at the lowest. If you are a great team.... you don't get beat @Ark, if you are a great team you don't only beat Bowling Green by 7 at home. 

 

Tennessee and PSU have handled NO ONE. 

"please be somewhat conservative in assessing IU's performance" No. We have lost 1 quarter all year. 1. Call it what it is... Indiana is a T10 team. They've shown that for 9 weeks. 

Agree….although I do think Tennessee has a great defense.  I feel like I’ve been pretty conservative and unbiased, as IU has won by a bigger margin than I’ve predicted in 7 of the 9 games.  And that’s with me thinking IU is about #5 right now.

Posted
29 minutes ago, IUHoosierJoe said:

Agree….although I do think Tennessee has a great defense.  I feel like I’ve been pretty conservative and unbiased, as IU has won by a bigger margin than I’ve predicted in 7 of the 9 games.  And that’s with me thinking IU is about #5 right now.

Tennessee's DL is disgustingly good. Literally winning games for them right now. 

Wanna know what neutralizes a great DL? ....a tremendous RPO game

Posted
4 minutes ago, Demo said:

The idea that the hottest rock star HC in the country is a slightly cranky 63yo 1st time power conference guy at the losingest program in history takes the term “counterintuitive” to whole new heights. Beyond awesome.

This is quite possibly the greatest post in the 30 years I have been on message boards.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...