General Coach Candidate News

[tyappleg 5,575]

1 minute ago, AH1971 said:

Cronin has made it past the first weekend three times in the last four seasons. Drew's made it twice in the last ten seasons. 

Drew has a higher overall achievement than Cronin (national title vs F4) but the rest of their resumes are nearly identical. 

Drew also has 2 additional Elite 8's.  This is asinine.  And Drew is doing at a school that made the NCAA Tournament ONE TIME since 1950 before he started there. 

[str8baller 6,358]

8 minutes ago, AH1971 said:

Isn't the majority of this board against hiring Tony Bennett? Didn't he win a national title?

Couldn’t tell ya…I’m very pro Tony Bennett. I’d put money on him winning a National Title and 3+ B1G titles before he retired if hired at IU. 

[Certified Sunshine Pumper 10,085]

Coming here to flex for Cronin should get you institutionalized. 

[Demo 21,777]

3 minutes ago, str8baller said:

Woodson/Archie hires are weird in that on day 1 we would all assume Woodson was a worse hire. But in results I don’t think it could get much worse than Archie. 

Archie’s as clean an example as we’ll  ever see of a guy just being too small for a job. From that 1st presser where he looked completely spooked to the Indiana State debacle where he had no answers at all. He was dead man walking. The rest was just shouting.

[JPCIVOP 220]

1 minute ago, AH1971 said:

There really isn't.

Drew's best season is better than Cronin's best season but using a nearly 20 year data set, they're very comparable.

Same number of NCAA Tourney wins for both coaches the last four years. Even with Drew's title. And it's true, the COVID rules made that a strange season. Those early exits are the knock against him.

I don't think Drew gets to coast on Baylor's lack of history forever; they've been making tournaments for 17 years. UCLA's 2008-2009 team is their last really good one; Cronin's done a good rebuild there, and this is closer than people think.

[Pagoda 2,636]

Uh oh.  This news is going to need to be factored in.

(jk… mostly)

[Uspshoosier 50,371]

6 minutes ago, AH1971 said:

Scott Drew had an exceptional season during COVID and hasn't duplicated anything close to that while at Baylor the last 20+ years. We call these outliers. 

He was having an exceptional season the year before that where his team was projected to be a 1 seed and one of the favorites going into that cancelled tourney 

they year after he won a title he was a 1 seed as well 

Projected 1 seed 

1 seed 

1seed 

3 seed

3 seed 

bubble 

those are his last 6 seasons.   Saying he had 1 good year and hasn’t duplicated that season wouldn’t be right in my opinion.  If you want to argue he underachieves in the tourney with what seeds his teams earn then I can see that argument.  
 

 if IU is to pull a sitting coach from a high major team it will be considered a home run in the industry especially if its from the B1G and SEC.  Fans are going to fan and some will like they hire and some won’t.   

[AH1971 2,054]

1 minute ago, tyappleg said:

Drew also has 2 additional Elite 8's.  This is asinine.  And Drew is doing at a school that made the NCAA Tournament ONE TIME since 1950 before he started there. 

14 and 16 years ago. Who cares? With the exception of the COVID year, Scott Drew teams flame out early every year which is exactly the knock @Certified Sunshine Pumper is using against Cronin (can't get past S16).

[Certified Sunshine Pumper 10,085]

Just now, AH1971 said:

14 and 16 years ago. Who cares? With the exception of the COVID year, Scott Drew teams flame out early every year which is exactly the knock @Certified Sunshine Pumper is using against Cronin (can't get past S16).

I'm using the knock that he doesn't exceed expectations anywhere, ever. 

[Stuhoo 85,464]

2 minutes ago, Demo said:

Archie’s as clean an example as we’ll  ever see of a guy just being too small for a job. From that 1st presser where he looked completely spooked to the Indiana State debacle where he had no answers at all. He was dead man walking. The rest was just shouting.

Archie Miller being introduced. HE LOOKS WORRIED!

[AH1971 2,054]

Just now, Uspshoosier said:

He was having an exceptional season the year before that where his team was projected to be a 1 seed and one of the favorites going into that cancelled tourney 

they year after he won a title he was a 1 seed as well 

Projected 1 seed 

1 seed 

1seed 

3 seed

3 seed 

bubble 

those are his last 6 seasons.   Saying he had 1 good year and hasn’t duplicated that season wouldn’t be right in my opinion.  If you want to argue he underachieves in the tourney with what seeds his teams earn then I can see that argument.  
 

 if IU is to pull a sitting coach from a high major team it will be considered a home run in the industry especially if its from the B1G and SEC.  Fans are going to fan and some will like they hire and some won’t.   

That's exactly what I'm arguing. The knock against Cronin is that he can't get past the S16. That was the knock on Crean....

Scott Drew has a long reputation of shitting the bed in March. That isn't a secret at all.

[tyappleg 5,575]

1 minute ago, AH1971 said:

14 and 16 years ago. Who cares? With the exception of the COVID year, Scott Drew teams flame out early every year which is exactly the knock @Certified Sunshine Pumper is using against Cronin (can't get past S16).

I guess I'll take the guy who has won a national championship and hasnt been able to win a 2nd one versus the guy who has no elite season to replicate. 

[Hovadipo 59,424]

4 minutes ago, Demo said:

Archie’s as clean an example as we’ll  ever see of a guy just being too small for a job.

You made me do this. 

[iu eyedoc 3,230]

5 minutes ago, Certified Sunshine Pumper said:

Do you mean, LAST SEASON, is cherry-picking? That's something. Wow. 

Oh you like current stuff. How about UCLA is a predictive 7 seed while Baylor is currently slated to be accepting a bid into the NIT.

[AH1971 2,054]

3 minutes ago, tyappleg said:

I guess I'll take the guy who has won a national championship and hasnt been able to win a 2nd one versus the guy who has no elite season to replicate. 

I'm not advocating Cronin over Drew, would take either in a heartbeat. I think it's wild that one person can be so dismissive of one coach over the other despite having almost identical pros and cons with nearly identical records.

[IUHoosierJoe 1,780]

29 minutes ago, IU Prof said:

I hope so, but I'm not sure this is consistent with how Goodman has been talking about the job the past couple weeks. I don't thinking he'd be pushing a guy like TJ Otzelberger if he knew Brad was already in the bag.

I also think the tweet would likely have been worded differently in that case, without the not a candidate bit.

Doesn't mean it's not Brad, just that I'm not convinced Goodman is in on the ruse.

Not saying he’s in on the ruse, but if he is, pushing other names out there would certainly be part of it.  The other names serve as a distraction from Stevens, and also may help some of the names he pushes get a pay raise from their current schools.  It’s a win for everyone.

[MrBBall 504]

5 minutes ago, Uspshoosier said:

He was having an exceptional season the year before that where his team was projected to be a 1 seed and one of the favorites going into that cancelled tourney 

they year after he won a title he was a 1 seed as well 

Projected 1 seed 

1 seed 

1seed 

3 seed

3 seed 

bubble 

those are his last 6 seasons.   Saying he had 1 good year and hasn’t duplicated that season wouldn’t be right in my opinion.  If you want to argue he underachieves in the tourney with what seeds his teams earn then I can see that argument.  
 

 if IU is to pull a sitting coach from a high major team it will be considered a home run in the industry especially if its from the B1G and SEC.  Fans are going to fan and some will like they hire and some won’t.   

Wouldn’t anyone take this??

[HoosierInParadise 928]

I'm not advocating Cronin over Drew, would take either in a heartbeat. I think it's wild that one person can be so dismissive of one coach over the other despite having almost identical pros and cons. 

Records and stats aside then, Cronin kind of annoys me and Drew doesn't when it comes to listening to them talk. I'd rather have Drew...

[Hoosierfanyuh 3,734]

8 minutes ago, Pagoda said:

Uh oh.  This news is going to need to be factored in.

(jk… mostly)

This is honestly a valid concern lol. They mean well and do raise decent amounts of money but them being that close with a coach is not fun to see haha

[lillurk 4,384]

9 minutes ago, Demo said:

Archie’s as clean an example as we’ll  ever see of a guy just being too small for a job. From that 1st presser where he looked completely spooked to the Indiana State debacle where he had no answers at all. He was dead man walking. The rest was just shouting.

Ran an errand at halftime of ISU and thought: we’re stuck with this shmuck for years. Game 1!