College Football Thread

[Hovadipo]

25 minutes ago, Lebowski said:

This is called gaslighting. 

 

It isn't "an idea", Kirk. You said it. Out loud. On TV. To like 10 million people.

His fall from grace is something else. Used to love the guy.

[go iu bb]

31 minutes ago, Hovadipo said:

It isn't "an idea", Kirk. You said it. Out loud. On TV. To like 10 million people.

His fall from grace is something else. Used to love the guy.

He's intentionally misrepresenting what the discussion was. He's now talking about the semi-finals and acting like that was what was being discussed before. It wasn't. It was about who should or shouldn't have even made it into the CFP. Strawman argument by him.

Also, he is trying to pretend like they wouldn't take Alabama over one of these schools? Really, we're supposed to believe that? Alabama isn't a big enough brand? Yeah, right. ESPN would take 'Bama over, say, Penn State in a heartbeat. He just has to pretend like they wouldn't since their previous whining backfired so spectacularly after the Tide lost yet another game but to say that they wouldn't love for Alabama to be in one of these games is disingenuous. 

Who was talking about Auburn in the CFP discussion? No one. They didn't even qualify for a bowl game.

[go iu bb]

Herbstreit getting called out. It's a week old but just showed up in my google news feed.

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6030482/2024/12/31/alabama-michigan-playoff-indiana-smu-herbstreit/

[Stuhoo]

2 hours ago, go iu bb said:

Herbstreit getting called out. It's a week old but just showed up in my google news feed.

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6030482/2024/12/31/alabama-michigan-playoff-indiana-smu-herbstreit/

That article is AWESOME

[Lebowski]

There's a whole discussion about IUFB in the interview and my blood is boiling. Because all three of them don't understand that a one loss P4 team will always get into a 12 team EXPANDED CFP! Deal with it. Ari Wasserman kind of explained it but then lost me when he said a 10-2 Bama should have gotten in over IUFB. 

 

[Pagoda]

18 minutes ago, Lebowski said:

There's a whole discussion about IUFB in the interview and my blood is boiling. Because all three of them don't understand that a one loss P4 team will always get into a 12 EXPANDED CFP! Deal with it. Ari Wasserman kind of explained it but then lost me when he said a 10-2 Bama should have gotten in over IUFB. 

 

The crap we get for losing AT (i) Ohio State, the likely national champs who are destroying everyone but UM (psychological issue), and (ii) ND, who is a CFP semi-finalist and maybe finalist, is so stupid.  We were bad in those games, but not notably or historically bad.  Sheesh.

I didn't listen to this, but the story any CFB advocate/talking head should be telling about IU is how a new staff in just one year with 15-20% of the resources of the big football schools won 11 games, and most of the wins were by healthy margins.  That's extraordinary and should be celebrated, but no, we get drivel and gaslighting from Kirk and the other idiots like him.  Pathetic.

[go iu bb]

8 minutes ago, Pagoda said:

The crap we get for losing AT (i) Ohio State, the likely national champs who are destroying everyone but UM (psychological issue), and (ii) ND, who is a CFP semi-finalist and maybe finalist, is so stupid.  We were bad in those games, but not notably or historically bad.  Sheesh.

I didn't listen to this, but the story any CFB advocate/talking head should be telling about IU is how a new staff in just one year with 15-20% of the resources of the big football schools won 11 games, and most of the wins were by healthy margins.  That's extraordinary and should be celebrated, but no, we get drivel and gaslighting from Kirk and the other idiots like him.  Pathetic.

It's funny. He says, "We love college football. We love stories." IU would've been a great story if that was the case. What you said plus the new coach brought in a bunch of players in from lower level schools. This is at the school which is traditionally bad.

Instead the story they decided on was to crap on IU.

[southsidehoosier]

https://www.thedailyhoosier.com/watch-kirk-herbstreit-talks-at-length-about-his-comments-on-indiana-big-ten-sec/?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR167C0SaVIpbPdRh7pY5vLRbEz6Mt4Ar59gzTSqvSxAkGGqchyEw-fBNs0_aem_tl4hP1qMH7F0sdgvwcqp6Q

[Magnanimous]

Kurtis Rourke threw more TD passes against Purdue than Herbstreit threw in his entire career at OSU. 

[RoadRage]

Notre Dame 31 - 17

[LIHoosier]

How in the world do you make a fair catch at your own 2?

[TheWatShot]

32 minutes ago, LIHoosier said:

How in the world do you make a fair catch at your own 2?

You still get it at the 20 if you fair catch it inside a certain point. I saw that earlier this year in one of our games and thought the refs had screwed up when they brought the ball to the 20. 

 

Edit: never mind, I guess that's only on kickoffs. 

[LIHoosier]

The kickoff rule is fair catches go to the 25, punts are fair game. Probably can chalk it up to that habit.

[LIHoosier]

1 hour ago, RoadRage said:

Notre Dame 31 - 17

Irish better get going or you're gonna have a negative score, haha

[RoadRage]

Just now, LIHoosier said:

Irish better get going or you're gonna have a negative score, haha

Penn State is dominating them!

[Hoosierfan1901]

Leonard in Concussion protocol 

[Hovadipo]

If Leonard comes back the concussion protocol is a farce. On SkyCast they zoomed in on him when he got up and he probably couldn’t tell you what planet he was on. Good job by that ref to notice it. 

[RoadRage]

3 minutes ago, Hovadipo said:

If Leonard comes back the concussion protocol is a farce. On SkyCast they zoomed in on him when he got up and he probably couldn’t tell you what planet he was on. Good job by that ref to notice it. 

They ask him what his favorite hobby was, he said "huh", they said that's right hunting, you are good to go!

[LIHoosier]

6 minutes ago, Hovadipo said:

If Leonard comes back the concussion protocol is a farce. On SkyCast they zoomed in on him when he got up and he probably couldn’t tell you what planet he was on. Good job by that ref to notice it. 

I was surprised he stayed on his feet after his linemen scraped him up like roadkill

[RoadRage]

That was a great drive by the Irish!