2018-2019 Rotation Discussion Thread

[AZ Hoosier]

25 minutes ago, Class of '66 Old Fart said:

Old guys rock!  

Indeed they (we) do...

[Hovadipo]

31 minutes ago, Hoosierfan2017 said:

Not only was that guy a dbag, his comment doesn't even make sense lol. Both are state schools and cost roughly the same amount per year. 

WELL ACTUALLY

 

[Napleshoosier]

I’m not quite sure what an “A$$-a-muck” is, but somehow that seems spot on.
Wish I was there to watch the mighty Nips slay the Purdooders in that bar.
Hell, I wish I was in any bar with NaplesHoosier!



Sent from my iPhone using BtownBanners mobile app

The d-bags wife had a Boiler shirt on and when I made that comment he sure got pissed! Lol. I mean really, I’m 60 and this buttwipe was early 30’s? Wtf? But he got told by an older guy his wife was f’n ugly! Lol


Sent from my iPad using BtownBanners mobile app

[Stuhoo]

The d-bags wife had a Boiler shirt on and when I made that comment he sure got pissed! Lol. I mean really, I’m 60 and this buttwipe was early 30’s? Wtf? But he got told by an older guy his wife was f’n ugly! Lol


Sent from my iPad using BtownBanners mobile app

I bet you were young enough to put a lil’ scare in him.



Sent from my iPhone using BtownBanners mobile app

[HoosierHoops1]

4 hours ago, Napleshoosier said:

OT....I’m at a bar in Naples, Fl Was walking back from the pisser and a guy taps me on the shoulder. Understand I have an IU shirt on and he says “ so you couldn’t afford to go to Purdue?” I smiled and said thank you for keeping all the ugly girls out of IU”! They really are d-bags! And his wife had a PU shirt one! A$$-a-mucks they are! Understand I’m 60 yrs old ok?

 

 

Sent from my iPad using BtownBanners

 

 

 

 

Hell no you couldn't afford to go to Purdue. Who can afford to waste 4 years on that ugly campus, looking at ugly girls, sitting in that ugly bannerless arena and dreaming about being in Btown?

[mdn82]

On 5/21/2018 at 12:36 AM, HoosierHoops1 said:

Hell no you couldn't afford to go to Purdue. Who can afford to waste 4 years on that ugly campus, looking at ugly girls, sitting in that ugly bannerless arena and dreaming about being in Btown?

I figured it would be too expensive using all that gas money to find half decent females.

[Brass Cannon]

Well its official i think we all agree have 2 players guaranteed to start. 

PG - Green/Phinisee

SG - Langford

SF - McRoberts/Smith/Hunter

PF - Morgan

C - Davis/Thompson/Fitzner

I know i am in the minority here but i really would start Mcroberts or Fitz they compliment Morgan and Romeo alot and they allow more talented players to come off the bench. 

Im also pretty sure Green will start. 

[HoosierAloha]

2 hours ago, Brass Cannon said:

Well its official i think we all agree have 2 players guaranteed to start. 

PG - Green/Phinisee

SG - Langford

SF - McRoberts/Smith/Hunter

PF - Morgan

C - Davis/Thompson/Fitzner

I know i am in the minority here but i really would start Mcroberts or Fitz they compliment Morgan and Romeo alot and they allow more talented players to come off the bench. 

Im also pretty sure Green will start. 

I believe we'll see Smith shooting jumpers more this season.  He has a good stroke and that would create more space for Morgan or a big to work down low.

[HoosierDYT]

Based on Archie's "positionless" basketball ideology and recent trends of small-ball, I think we could start Green, Langford, Hunter, Smith, Morgan.  What we lose in height we gain in speed, possibly. 

[HoosierX]

52 minutes ago, HoosierDYT said:

Based on Archie's "positionless" basketball ideology and recent trends of small-ball, I think we could start Green, Langford, Hunter, Smith, Morgan.  What we lose in height we gain in speed, possibly. 

I could see that.

I mean that lineup would go 6'1, 6'5, 6'7, 6'7, 6'8...not exactly a short lineup.

[Old Friend]

1)  All due respect to Brass Cannon,  if we have to start McRoberts in any circumstance, I think we're in trouble.   He is not at all a threat to score, and we don't need that liability on the floor with starters' minutes this season.  Love him as a role player off the bench, but he should not be listed anywhere as a starter.  He is still a walk on, after all

2)  I may die on this hill, but I'm remaining firmly in the "Phinisee should start from day 1" camp.  I may also be alone in that tent, but he is a pure point guard and I truly believe at least as good as Yogi was at this age.  Quicker and not as strong, so not really comparable; but he's terrific.  Green to me is a combo guard and still makes too many mistakes to start with a team this talented.

3)  I would love at some point to see Smith get a shot at the "3."   He should be the guy on a rim run on every fast break.

4)  Don't be surprised to see Race Thompson in the mix in the front court.  I haven't heard much (I also haven't asked), but what I DO hear is that he's a strong SOB and tough to move around in the paint.  

5)  I am also of the belief that Davis will contribute more this season than many think he will.  Maybe Fitzner can fill the "5" role until he's ready or can play big minutes, but I know plenty of people who have come back to 100% from an achilles tear in less than 9 months.  

If I were making decisions, I'd start : Phinisee, Langford, Smith, Morgan, and Davis/Thompson/Fitzner.  Maybe Archie will ask for my input?

[Brass Cannon]

32 minutes ago, Old Friend said:

1)  All due respect to Brass Cannon,  if we have to start McRoberts in any circumstance, I think we're in trouble.   He is not at all a threat to score, and we don't need that liability on the floor with starters' minutes this season.  Love him as a role player off the bench, but he should not be listed anywhere as a starter.  He is still a walk on, after all

2)  I may die on this hill, but I'm remaining firmly in the "Phinisee should start from day 1" camp.  I may also be alone in that tent, but he is a pure point guard and I truly believe at least as good as Yogi was at this age.  Quicker and not as strong, so not really comparable; but he's terrific.  Green to me is a combo guard and still makes too many mistakes to start with a team this talented.

3)  I would love at some point to see Smith get a shot at the "3."   He should be the guy on a rim run on every fast break.

4)  Don't be surprised to see Race Thompson in the mix in the front court.  I haven't heard much (I also haven't asked), but what I DO hear is that he's a strong SOB and tough to move around in the paint.  

5)  I am also of the belief that Davis will contribute more this season than many think he will.  Maybe Fitzner can fill the "5" role until he's ready or can play big minutes, but I know plenty of people who have come back to 100% from an achilles tear in less than 9 months.  

If I were making decisions, I'd start : Phinisee, Langford, Smith, Morgan, and Davis/Thompson/Fitzner.  Maybe Archie will ask for my input?

No offense but if you think Mcroberts is just a walk on after all then im just going to not read the rest of the post. 

About 180 scholarship basketball players in the Big Ten last year. Mcroberts probably easily outplayed 60 of them. 

And you dont always play your 5 besr players or do you think the Pacers orgabozation thought that Jeff Foster was better than Al Harrington. 

[Old Friend]

2 minutes ago, Brass Cannon said:

No offense but if you think Mcroberts is just a walk on after all then im just going to not read the rest of the post. 

About 180 scholarship basketball players in the Big Ten last year. Mcroberts probably easily outplayed 60 of them. 

And you dont always play your 5 besr players or do you think the Pacers orgabozation thought that Jeff Foster was better than Al Harrington. 

He is a walk on.  That's a fact.   Regardless of how you spin it....that's what he is.   How he plays or the role he plays is irrelevant.  He is a walk on.  You don't start walk on's who can't score if you're competing for a Big Ten title.  I don't care if you read the rest of the post or not...but you did.    I am completely aware of how you build a team and what you put on the floor...I've only coached for 21 years. 

Any player in the NBA who starts is an expert at something.  Foster was one of the best post defenders and rebounders in the eastern conference.  He was also a 5.  Harrington was a 3-4, so I'm not sure what point you're trying to make with that comparison, but for all McRoberts is; find me a Big Ten champ who consistently started a walk on who can't score.  I said I like him off the bench, and I do; but who does he start in front of?   Smith?  Langford?  Not on any team that thinks it's very good.

[Stuhoo]

1)  All due respect to Brass Cannon,  if we have to start McRoberts in any circumstance, I think we're in trouble.   He is not at all a threat to score, and we don't need that liability on the floor with starters' minutes this season.  Love him as a role player off the bench, but he should not be listed anywhere as a starter.  He is still a walk on, after all
2)  I may die on this hill, but I'm remaining firmly in the "Phinisee should start from day 1" camp.  I may also be alone in that tent, but he is a pure point guard and I truly believe at least as good as Yogi was at this age.  Quicker and not as strong, so not really comparable; but he's terrific.  Green to me is a combo guard and still makes too many mistakes to start with a team this talented.
3)  I would love at some point to see Smith get a shot at the "3."   He should be the guy on a rim run on every fast break.
4)  Don't be surprised to see Race Thompson in the mix in the front court.  I haven't heard much (I also haven't asked), but what I DO hear is that he's a strong SOB and tough to move around in the paint.  
5)  I am also of the belief that Davis will contribute more this season than many think he will.  Maybe Fitzner can fill the "5" role until he's ready or can play big minutes, but I know plenty of people who have come back to 100% from an achilles tear in less than 9 months.  
If I were making decisions, I'd start : Phinisee, Langford, Smith, Morgan, and Davis/Thompson/Fitzner.  Maybe Archie will ask for my input?

Yes to #3 & #4.
Disagree with #1, #2, and #5.



Sent from my iPhone using BtownBanners mobile app

[Old Friend]

2 minutes ago, Stuhoo said:

Yes to #3 & #4.
Disagree with #1, #2, and #5.



Sent from my iPhone using BtownBanners mobile app

I think everyone disagrees with me on #2.  Maybe #1, too because people (rightfully) fell in love w McRoberts.  Yep...he is a winning player, but on a team with as much talent and athletic ability as this one has, I see him as a far bigger contributor off the bench than I do playing starter's minutes.

[Brass Cannon]

7 minutes ago, Old Friend said:

I think everyone disagrees with me on #2.  Maybe #1, too because people (rightfully) fell in love w McRoberts.  Yep...he is a winning player, but on a team with as much talent and athletic ability as this one has, I see him as a far bigger contributor off the bench than I do playing starter's minutes.

You dont need a lockdown defender off the bench. And with Juwan and Romeo we wont need 5 guys who can score starting. 

To not start a guy simply because he is a walk on regardless of ability is just silly. I suppose Bryce Alford shouldnt have started his senior year. Despite averaging over 15 points

[Stuhoo]

I think everyone disagrees with me on #2.  Maybe #1, too because people (rightfully) fell in love w McRoberts.  Yep...he is a winning player, but on a team with as much talent and athletic ability as this one has, I see him as a far bigger contributor off the bench than I do playing starter's minutes.

I think your post was excellent, and that you did a really nice job stating your case. Also, I often agree with your thoughts on how the team will flow, especially lately!

Funny thing is, the biggest disagreement I have with you is on your point number five! Especially after last night’s statements by Archie, I am pretty much completely convinced that the chances of Davis being a contributor this year are slim to none.



Sent from my iPhone using BtownBanners mobile app

[Brass Cannon]

Also i am getting less bullish on Green starting. Spent time looking at stats today and its extremely rare for guards to take a big leap soph to junior year. Much more common for 4 star freshman to make an instant impact

[Class of '66 Old Fart]

41 minutes ago, Old Friend said:

I think everyone disagrees with me on #2.  

 Not me.  I've watched enough of Phinisee's games over the past couple of years and I think he's the real deal.  He'll shoot if he has to, but he's always going to be looking for the open shooter first and he's going to take excellent care of the ball.  Laugh if you want, but he'll end up in the top 5 (maybe 3) in career assists when he's finished.

[Brass Cannon]

18 minutes ago, Class of '66 Old Fart said:

 Not me.  I've watched enough of Phinisee's games over the past couple of years and I think he's the real deal.  He'll shoot if he has to, but he's always going to be looking for the open shooter first and he's going to take excellent care of the ball.  Laugh if you want, but he'll end up in the top 5 (maybe 3) in career assists when he's finished.

If he starts day 1 i think he could be number 1 with the talent that Archie appears to be surrounding him with