IU vs MSU Post Game Thread

[barrettballer 513]

Except he didn't, Sudfeld outplayed him against Navy, Minnesota, and the Ohio State game he threw the ball better. Also, against Bowling Green, Penn State, Illinois and Bowling Green, Sudfeld looked good in all four of those games. That is half the games where Nate got the majority of the snaps and looked good. Those are 7 games, I'll give you 6 since the Ohio State game is arguable they were equally mediocre in a blow out. How exactly did Tre outplay Nate most of the season again when 2 or 3 of the games I didn't list were blowouts.

It's hard to say Sudfeld out played Roberson in those games when Roberson didn't hardly even play in Bowling Green, Navy, and Penn State. No one played well in the OSU game or Wisconsin game. Sudfeld blew the navy game with a pick 6. I'll give you the Minnesota game but the Bowling Green and Illinois defenses were not good. I say sudfeld played well against Penn State and Illinois. The Minnesota game was mostly a mix of Stephen Houston and TC running all over the defense. Plus Sudfeld contributed to the late turnover (Not all his fault bad play call) but it was a very very poor decision.

[KingPG21 6,587]

It's hard to say Sudfeld out played Roberson in those games when Roberson didn't hardly even play in Bowling Green, Navy, and Penn State. No one played well in the OSU game or Wisconsin game. Sudfeld blew the navy game with a pick 6. I'll give you the Minnesota game but the Bowling Green and Illinois defenses were not good. I say sudfeld played well against Penn State and Illinois. The Minnesota game was mostly a mix of Stephen Houston and TC running all over the defense. Plus Sudfeld contributed to the late turnover (Not all his fault bad play call) but it was a very very poor decision.

Wait, wait, wait, hold up a second. Sudfeld blew the game with a pick 6. But Tre doing absolutely nothing on two drives and not just one play didn't? Also, you give credit to Tre for 15 touchdowns, when 8 came against Purdue and ISU who are putrid, but Bowling Green (Who won the MAC) and Illinois don't count for Sudfeld. How exactly does that work

[barrettballer 513]

Wait, wait, wait, hold up a second. Sudfeld blew the game with a pick 6. But Tre doing absolutely nothing on two drives and not just one play didn't? Also, you give credit to Tre for 15 touchdowns, when 8 came against Purdue and ISU who are putrid, but Bowling Green (Who won the MAC) and Illinois don't count for Sudfeld. How exactly does that work

I'm saying that if Tre's good games against not good defenses don't count why should Sudfeld's? So you're saying that a dropped screen pass, handoffs and one QB run is enough to decide if someone shouldn't play for the rest of the game? Yes blew it. His pass was way underthrown. I'm not saying the navy game is all his fault because our defense was trash but big mistakes like that certainly didn't help our chances

Edit: The Mac is not a strong conference by any means. The best team they played was Northern Illinois and their entire offense was basically Jordan Lynch. Don't get me wrong winning a conference is impressive but they didn't beat any power conference teams.

[KingPG21 6,587]

I'm saying that if Tre's good games against not good defenses don't count why should Sudfeld's? So you're saying that a dropped screen pass, handoffs and one QB run is enough to decide if someone shouldn't play for the rest of the game? Yes blew it. His pass was way underthrown. I'm not saying the navy game is all his fault because our defense was trash but big mistakes like that certainly didn't help our chances

We're just going to have to agree to disagree. I don't think either one was clearly better than the other last season

[barrettballer 513]

We're just going to have to agree to disagree. I don't think either one was clearly better than the other last season

Yes agree to disagree is good. No sense in continuing to fight with a fellow Hoosier fan.